ENGL 373: Science Fiction and Fantasy

What is peer-reviewed?

This is a process a where recognized experts on a topic read and review the article before it is published in a journal. Most of the time the review process is anonymous and both the author and reviewer are not identified. The reason for this is to eliminate any personal bias in the review process. During the review process, the article will be evaluated on the accuracy of the information in the article, and reliability of the research methods used, and the overall quality of the research presented in the article.

The Peer review process answers the following questions:

• Is the research valid and credible?
• Are research design and methodology appropriate?
• Is this research significant and the findings important?
• Is the research original and new?
• Does the paper properly cite the previous work done by others?
• Should this work be published, improved or rejected.  

 Who is an expert?

•  Experts are recognized authorities on a topic. You can identify someone’s authority by their education, credentials, and affiliation.
• Look for academic degrees such as PhD. For scholarly articles the educational background and degrees of the author should be easy to find.
• Look at where the author is employed. If it is a university this is a good sign. Generally experts will be employed (affiliated) with some organization such as a university, corporation or government.
• The author and their degrees are visible.
• The author's affiliation and contact information will be visible

What does a Primary Research Article look like?

• All primary research articles will share many of the same characteristics
• There will usually be a paragraph labeled abstract at the beginning of the article. This abstract will be a brief summary of the article, and is intended to help the reader determine if the article is on the topic of interest. You can also see that the authors and their affiliations are clearly shown.